Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item: http://hdl.handle.net/1822/59689

TitleFrom Gist of a Wink to Structural Equivalence of Meaning: Towards a Cross-Cultural Psychology of the Collective Remembering of World History
Author(s)Liu, James H.
Paez, Dario
Techio, Elza
Slawuta, Patricia
Zlobina, Anya
Cabecinhas, Rosa
KeywordsSocial representations
Social representations of history
Collective remembering
Cultural psychology
Cultural anthropology
Hermeneutics
World War II
Willingness to fight
Issue date2010
PublisherSAGE
JournalJournal of Cross-Cultural Psychology
CitationLiu, J. H. et al. (2010). From Gist of a Wink to Structural Equivalence of Meaning: Towards a Cross-Cultural Psychology of the Collective Remembering of World History. Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology, 41(3), 451–456. DOI: 10.1177/0022022109359695
Abstract(s)Gibson and Noret’s (2010 [this issue]) critique of Paez et al.’s (2008) article on “remembering” World War II and willingness to fight applies social constructionist epistemologies based on hermeneutics to large-scale cross-cultural research. In criticizing our operationalization of historical experience, they privilege micro-analysis of discursive features that cannot be applied equally to different cultures; with regards to remembering, they identify the context-specific evocation of a particular aspect of collective remembering with collective memory in general. Their criticism of the wording of the central question on willingness to fight for one’s country is misplaced because this item comes from country-level data from the World Values Survey. Our work, involving 3,322 participants from 22 societies with at least 14 different majority languages, provides analysis of a general phenomenon and cannot be expected to incorporate micro-analysis of local discursive features. Cross-cultural psychology has advanced into a position of international prominence by using quantitative measures to construct nomological or associational networks that create complementary (and alternative) conceptions of meaning to the “thick descriptions” of ethnography favored by cultural anthropology. A division of labor with respect to these fields and across projects is recommended.
TypeArticle
URIhttp://hdl.handle.net/1822/59689
DOI10.1177/0022022109359695
ISSN00220221
e-ISSN15525422
Publisher versionhttps://journals.sagepub.com/doi/pdf/10.1177/0022022109359695
Peer-Reviewedyes
AccessRestricted access (Author)
Appears in Collections:CECS - Artigos em revistas internacionais / Articles in international journals

Files in This Item:
File Description SizeFormat 
2010_Liu-et-al_From-Gist-of-a-Wink-to-Structural-Equivalence-of-Meaning.pdf
  Restricted access
111,18 kBAdobe PDFView/Open

Partilhe no FacebookPartilhe no TwitterPartilhe no DeliciousPartilhe no LinkedInPartilhe no DiggAdicionar ao Google BookmarksPartilhe no MySpacePartilhe no Orkut
Exporte no formato BibTex mendeley Exporte no formato Endnote Adicione ao seu ORCID